The Holy Communion

Home Forums All Things Catholic The Holy Communion

This topic contains 18 replies, has 6 voices, and was last updated by  Uncertaindrummer 10 years, 2 months ago.

Viewing 19 posts - 1 through 19 (of 19 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1040

    PEZ
    Member

    I’ve notice that in other denominations when they do the holy communion, all the people who are participating are given the eucharist(or cracker in some churches) and some grape juice or wine. And so they are all taking in the body and blood of Christ.

    However, in all Catholic churches I’ve attended mass in, it’s only parish members who are given both the Eucharis and Wine. <img src=:” title=”Question” /> Why aren’t the rest of the people who attend the holy mass given the wine/grape juice, and instead only the body of Christ(Eucharist)? <img src=:” title=”Question” />

    Personally I love drinking the grape juice along with the Eucharist, it gives me a sense of “fullness” and “cleansing”. I would like it if I could have both of them. <img src=” title=”Very Happy” />

    #4362

    Victor
    Member

    Someone beat you to the puch already Rick. Refer to the link.

    [url:2d6vrw2o]http://www.aboutcatholics.com/community/viewtopic.php?t=564[/url:2d6vrw2o]

    By the way, the Eucharist is actually EITHER the wine OR the wafer. Either one will suffice for you to receive our Lord Christ.

    ~Victor

    #4363

    Victor
    Member

    Also, protestants do not believe in the Eucharist Rick. They don’t see it in the same way at all. To them it’s just a cracker and grape juice. That’s it.

    ~Victor

    #4364

    PEZ
    Member

    Yeah that’s why I put in cracker and grape juice. It seemed very awkward when I saw that.

    #4365

    PEZ
    Member

    [quote:1p2dmv6a]By the way, the Eucharist is actually EITHER the wine OR the wafer. Either one will suffice for you to receive our Lord Christ. [/quote:1p2dmv6a]

    What if someone wants to take both? Do they have to be a member of the volunteers during the mass?

    #4407

    emesina
    Member

    At the mass we attend, most people take both. The volunteers are standing in a position where it forces you to pass by the bread, then the wine to get back to your seat…but it’s your choice if you want to take one or both.

    #4422

    Andres Ortiz
    Keymaster

    Correction, people [b:1bxy8pxv]receive[/b:1bxy8pxv] the Eucharist, not take it. <img src=” title=”Wink” />

    #4426

    Siberian
    Member

    [quote:1m9xgnie]Also, protestants do not believe in the Eucharist Rick. They don’t see it in the same way at all. To them it’s just a cracker and grape juice. That’s it.
    [/quote:1m9xgnie]
    Well, I dont like to bash, I like to keep an open mind… so… Where did you hear that? I am a protestant and I thourougly (spelling? Im tired <img src=” title=”Razz” />) that when I participate in Communion that the actions I am taking are symbolising the body of Christ. The actions that night at the table, and His death on the cross. I take it very seriously. Im sure there are a few people groups in both faiths that see it as just a cracker and juice, but for the most part, I know where I go to Church it is taken very seriously.

    Siberian

    #4431

    Andres Ortiz
    Keymaster

    [quote:d2uidtd3]…when I participate in Communion that the actions I am taking are symbolising the body of Christ.[/quote:d2uidtd3]
    See, that’s the difference though. We believe that the bread and wine are transformed into the literal body and blood of Christ. It is not just a mere symbol. That’s what he meant when he said “Protestants do not believe in the Eucharist.”

    #4434

    Victor
    Member

    Siberian, Jon took the words right out of my mouth. By they way, there is that possibility that some protestants may see it as the literal Body and Blood of Christ. I’ve just never heard of any. My statement was just a general statement. It would be merely impossible for me to know the details of every single denomination out there (too many of you). But your statement of it being just a symbol seems to support my findings. <img src=” title=”Smile” />

    ~Victor

    #4436

    Siberian
    Member

    So you believe that while participating in the Eucharist the bread actually becomes flesh? And the wine actually becomes blood? Hmmm…. Jesus didnt do that at the last supper. They ate bread and wine. He merely used them as a demonstration that His body was about to be broken and His blood about to be spilled for the sins and remissions of many. I could be off in my thinking but… Blood and Flesh? :shock:

    #4438

    Andres Ortiz
    Keymaster

    [quote:17gkskyz]Hmmm…. Jesus didnt do that at the last supper.[/quote:17gkskyz]
    Sure he did. Read those Scriptures again. Jesus says “this [b:17gkskyz]is[/b:17gkskyz] my body” and “this [b:17gkskyz]is[/b:17gkskyz] my blood” not “this represents my body” and “this represents my blood.”

    Also, read John 6 and in particular verses 51 and beyond. Then post your thoughts. <img src=” title=”Smile” />

    #4443

    Siberian
    Member

    You have officialy changed my view on this <img src=” title=”Very Happy” /><img src=” title=”Smile” /> and thank you.

    Siberian

    #4444

    Andres Ortiz
    Keymaster

    [quote:8d1g36og]You have officialy changed my view on this <img src=” title=”Very Happy” /><img src=” title=”Smile” /> and thank you.[/quote:8d1g36og]
    Wow, that was quick, lol. I was hoping for more discussion. <img src=” title=”Razz” />

    #4454

    WHOA!! Quickest end to an argument I have ever seen. Somehow I thought practical Apologetics would be a little more difficult… lol

    I wonder though, if Siberian realizes that what Protestants do is NOT what Jesus did, since Protestants do not have the Priesthood. Not trying to be divisive, though.

    I’m glad your opinion changed on the subject.

    #4459

    Siberian
    Member

    Hmm, what do you mean by they dont have priesthood therefore they do not do the same thing. Do you have to have a priesthood to be able to lead a communion then?

    Siberian

    #4466

    For it to be the Body and Blood of Jesus Christ, yes. Jesus instituted His church, to, among other things, have Bishops and Priests capable of consecrating the bread and wine, which then becomes His Body and Blood.

    Protestant ministers are not Priests–or even Catholic–and as such cannot do this. Even if they COULD, though, they wouldn’t because they don’t BELIEVE that the bread and wine can possibly change into the Body and Blood. If they did, they would be Catholic! lol

    #4476

    Andres Ortiz
    Keymaster

    [quote:3uxm8cxe]Even if they COULD, though, they wouldn’t because they don’t BELIEVE that the bread and wine can possibly change into the Body and Blood. If they did, they would be Catholic! lol[/quote:3uxm8cxe]
    Or Orthodox or Episcopalian.

    Although the Episcopalian belief is that Jesus is there if you believe him to be and not if you don’t believe. I’m not sure if they believe transubstantiation (like us) or consubstantiation (like Lutherans).

    #4480

    Well, I was trying to simplify things when I said Catholic. But yes, Orthodox Churches do have the priesthood, and actually CAN consecrate the Host.

    Episcopalians believe in consubstantiation as far as I know.

Viewing 19 posts - 1 through 19 (of 19 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.