Home Forums All Things Catholic Doctrinal Diversity existing in Protestantism & Catholic Reply To: Doctrinal Diversity existing in Protestantism & Catholic


For me, as a Protestant, there is doctrine and there is Doctrine.

Little d doctrine involves something like prayer to priestly celibacy. Although I don’t have a problem with this as a doctine (much scripture can back this up without having to stand on one’s theological head), although as a Presbyterian the notion of Priest gives pause. In the PC, we have no priest, no altar. Theological reason is that Christ has made the one sacrifice and we don’t need to replicate it.

Big D doctine would be the diety of Christ. If He wasn’t God and man, his sacrifice would be problematic.

How do you feel about that?

As for infant baptism, some Evangelical churches forbid infant baptism on the grounds that baptism doesn’t save, Christ does. Others (mine, f’r instance) practice it because of other scriptural reasons (salvation promised to a believer and his family). But it doesn’t preclude fellowship, or it isn’t supposed to.