March 29, 2005 at 2:58 am #1001AnonymousInactive
I was having a discussion at dinner with the family and the following questions popped up:
Can God Love someone unconditionally but still have that person in hell?
Our relationship with God is conditional or unconditional?
Which supercedes, Love or Justice?
Let me know your thoughts.
~VictorMarch 29, 2005 at 4:42 am #4005About Catholics TeamKeymaster
[quote:1ofnkj6l]Can God Love someone unconditionally but still have that person in hell?[/quote:1ofnkj6l]
Yes, because the person chose not to love God. God doesn’t put people in hell, people choose to be in hell.
[quote:1ofnkj6l]Our relationship with God is conditional or unconditional?[/quote:1ofnkj6l]
Based on the information here I would say conditional – that we accept it. However, maybe you mean something different. Please feel free to elaborate.
[quote:1ofnkj6l]Which supercedes, Love or Justice?[/quote:1ofnkj6l]
I think justice naturally stems from love. If you truly love God and love your neighbor then you would want justice for society.March 29, 2005 at 5:42 am #4008AnonymousInactive
Agreed on everything you said. What you said is basically what my thoughts were as well. Just wanted to get some more thoughts from others.
~VictorApril 9, 2005 at 5:01 pm #4114About Catholics TeamKeymaster
I would agree about the answers too. ” title=”Smile” />April 12, 2005 at 3:16 pm #4125AnonymousInactive
[quote:2qeb3be4]Yes, because the person chose not to love God. God doesn’t put people in hell, people choose to be in hell.[/quote:2qeb3be4]
The catachism refers to this as free will. A gift God gave all creatures in creation. The catachism explains he did this to express his love and by giving us free will WE can choose to love him or not. This is how true love is expressed through choice not force.
[quote:2qeb3be4]Our relationship with God is conditional or unconditional?[/quote:2qeb3be4]
This is tricky, it’s conditional in the case of your salvation. If you choose not to love God then you will be damned. Now if you choose to love and serve God you have met the conditions to work towards your salvation and enjoy the gaces of God. Like I said its a tricky topic becuase of the terms used.
[quote:2qeb3be4]Which supercedes, Love or Justice?[/quote:2qeb3be4]
God is a God of love and a Just God. The go hand in hand. Your love and service to God is balanced with the Justice you recieve for service and sin. he forgives always when you seek the forgiveness, but he is Just too. So there is ALWAYS pentence to pay (justice).
This can get even deeper when the catachism and canon are applied in more depth.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.