Again twinc, you have an interpretation which departs from what the Catholic Church has taught. An interesting but abbarent interpretation. After reading some of your postings on other forums where you were banned, it would seem you put more credence in Protestant authors who deny that the Catholic Church or it’s claims are valid, and have influenced your theology, allowing you the “personal freedom” to decide for yourself what the Church teaches. A sign that prayers for you are still in order.