Home › Forums › All Things Catholic › Question about Hans Kung
- This topic has 1 reply, 2 voices, and was last updated 18 years, 12 months ago by About Catholics Team.
March 30, 2004 at 3:00 pm #809AnonymousInactive
So my brother gave me a book for christmas – ‘The Catholic Church: A Short History’ by Hans Kung. He wants me to read it so we’ll argue about it.
And after the first 20 pages, I’m not so thrilled with Kung, and I want to stop reading the book. Has anybody read it, or does anyone know about Kung’s recent work, what I should expect?
Dave ” title=”Smile” />March 30, 2004 at 3:27 pm #2828
I do not know a whole lot about Hans Kung, but I certainly would like to. I have hear many things about him ranging from that he is a great theologian to he is apostate. I have read small bits of works of which he was the chief editor and they were pretty sound theologically, but other than that the man is a mystery to me.
Is your brother not Catholic?March 30, 2004 at 3:37 pm #2829AnonymousInactive
Is your brother not Catholic?[/quote:i4h0h9o6]
He’s Catholic… just not happy with the Church.March 30, 2004 at 3:46 pm #2830
That’s too bad. ” title=”Sad” /> Why not? Is it the doctrine or something else?March 30, 2004 at 3:57 pm #2831AnonymousInactive
[quote:k27t0u0c]That’s too bad. ” title=”Sad” /> Why not? Is it the doctrine or something else?[/quote:k27t0u0c]
Honestly, it’s anything & everything. He doesn’t like Church authority, or it’s use thereof. He doesn’t like the teachings, the moral principles, the music, The mistakes that have been made, the mistakes that haven’t been made, the pope, his cardinals, the local priest, everything.
He likes his godson. And to be the godfather, he has to be a practicing catholic.
Dave ” title=”Smile” />
I’m a junior member? Already! Gadzooks!March 30, 2004 at 4:46 pm #2832
[quote:2bq8d5c0]…The mistakes that have been made, the mistakes that haven’t been made…[/quote:2bq8d5c0]
Ha ha ha that’s pretty funny (the mistakes that haven’t been made). ” title=”Wink” />
As far as the music goes just tell him to go to another parish – I’m sure it will have a different liturgy.
So then what is he happy with? Any other church?
[quote:2bq8d5c0]I’m a junior member? Already! Gadzooks![/quote:2bq8d5c0]
Yep, and with a few more posts you will move up again. With each one they get spaced out quite a bit more. No one has hit the 4th “rank” yet, but I’m sure it will happen soon enough. Don’t spam the boards to get there though – it’s not worth it. ” title=”Wink” /> ” title=”Very Happy” />
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.