November 20, 2009 at 5:32 am #1945AnonymousInactive
God love you!November 21, 2009 at 3:57 pm #9461About Catholics TeamKeymaster
What do you mean by “wrong”? Are you talking about the reduced number of books in their bibles?November 23, 2009 at 4:19 am #9466AnonymousInactive
Well, yeah that’s one…Are there any protestant bibles that have the dueterocanons?
I was also wondering if all their translations are absolutely wrong
Another thing, is Jehovah also wrong and that it should be Yahweh?
Thanks!November 23, 2009 at 6:52 am #9468AnonymousInactive
Jehovah is pronunciation that some German Biblical scholars thought that the Name of God would have been pronounced like. Even saying Yaweh, as it is spelled is not exact. The text of the Old Testament in Hebrew does not have vowels, and the Name is held so holy that an observant Jew will not pronounce it.
As to the History of how the Biblical Canon was decided on by the Catholic Church, with the guidance of the Holy Spirit, there are any number of websites that discuss the history. And when and why most Protestants edited out the deuterocanonicals is a complex history.
One of the problems with arguing the subject with Protestants is they have been taught that the Catholic Church “Added” the Deuterocanonicals at the Council of Trent. They truly believe the distorted history they have been taught, and much like the Iglesia Ni Christo, are taught that the Catholic Church had supressed the truth. For a Catholic exlanation on the Canon of Scripture, read this website.November 24, 2009 at 3:38 am #9473AnonymousInactive
Does anyone here also know why the epistles of pope clement were not included in the bible?
I mean what if it was included? There probably wouldn’t be any fractures in Christianity today…November 29, 2009 at 9:53 pm #9474AnonymousInactive
It would be nice to believe that there would be no fractures in the Church today if only one Letter, (I Clement) had been included in the New Testamtent. I doubt that even if I Clement was included it would have prevented the schisms we see today. Our Lord Himself saw that there would be those who following their own pride would establish rival sects, and teach false teachings. Among the issues that we sometimes forget, or were never taught is while writings like the Epistles of Clement, the Shepherd of Hermas, and the Didichae are ancient writings that one or another individual community saw as Scripture, they were forgotten for centuries, and only found again in the mid 1700’s and 1800’s. After the Bible was canonized by the Catholic Church, some of the writings of the Fathers existed on the shelves of libraries in the ancient world, with the development of Monastic communities in the Eastern Church, some of these were preserved in monastic libraries. It was not until the 1660’s that the First and Second Epistle of Clement were seen in the West, when they were given as a gift to King Charles I of England by the Patriarch of Constantinople (Orthodox). It has been since that time that some of the wrtinings of the Fathers which we only knew of because they were mentioned in other writers works became well known to us. Even though they do not compose a part of the New Testament, they are very important for us to understand both what the Early Church taught, and what the early Heretical teachers taught. Even among the Early Fathers writings, we see heretics like Tertullian, and others. They show us how one can be learned in the Faith, and then stray from the truth by becoming excessive in our trust in our own selves, rather than the Church, who Jesus Himself promised He would remain with.
Among the criteria for the selection of the New Testament that the Church used the four most important included thses.
1.Apostolic Origin – attributed to and/or based on the preaching/teaching of the first-generation apostles (or their closest companions).
2.Universal Acceptance – acknowledged by all major Christian communities in the Mediterranean world (by the end of the fourth century).
3.Liturgical Use – read publicly along with the OT when early Christians gathered for the Liturgy on the Lord’s Day, (Sunday).
4.Consistent Message – containing theological ideas compatible with other accepted Christian writings (incl. the divinity and humanity Jesus).
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.